RBA Confirmed: Card surcharges will be banned from 1 October 2026 — check you're on the right rate →

Compare providers  /  Square Alternatives

Square Alternatives in Australia

Square is a solid, easy-to-use option for many Australian businesses, with simple flat-rate pricing and quick setup. As your turnover grows, though, a flat percentage on every transaction can start to feel expensive, and you may want features Square does not emphasise. That is when it pays to look at how other providers price and package their services so you can match the right tool to how your business actually trades.

Common reasons to explore alternatives include higher card volumes that make negotiated or interchange-style rates worth chasing, a preference for local EFTPOS hardware with deep point-of-sale integrations, or wanting a bundled business transaction account alongside your terminal. This guide gives a fair, independent overview of three popular paths so you can shortlist providers, then confirm current pricing and terms with each one directly.

Tyro
Established and higher-volume retail and hospitality venues that rely on tight point-of-sale integration and want EFTPOS-focused support.

Strengths

  • EFTPOS specialist with broad integrations across many Australian POS and practice-management systems
  • Pricing models can include interchange-style or negotiated structures that may favour higher card turnover

Consider

  • May involve more setup and account requirements than a plug-and-play reader, so it suits businesses ready to commit
Tyro generally moves away from a single flat rate toward volume-aware or negotiated models; confirm current rates and terms directly.
Zeller
Australian small and growing businesses wanting simple flat-rate card acceptance bundled with a free business transaction account and card.

Strengths

  • Australian-built offering that pairs a terminal with an integrated business account, debit card and dashboard
  • Transparent flat-rate model with no lock-in contracts, which keeps things predictable for newer businesses

Consider

  • A flat-rate model can become less competitive as your card volume climbs, similar to other flat-rate providers
Zeller typically advertises a single flat percentage per transaction; verify the current rate and any account fees directly.
Major bank EFTPOS (e.g. CBA)
Businesses that prefer keeping payments, lending and banking under one established institution, and that may negotiate on volume.

Strengths

  • Backed by a large, established bank with bundled banking, lending and integrated settlement
  • Rates and plans are often negotiable for businesses with meaningful card turnover

Consider

  • Plans can be more complex, sometimes involving terminal rental, monthly fees or minimum terms to compare carefully
Major banks typically offer plan-based or negotiated merchant pricing rather than one flat rate; request a tailored quote directly.

Our take

There is no single best Square alternative, only the best fit for how you trade. If you are a newer or smaller business that values simple, predictable pricing and a built-in business account, Zeller maps closely to Square's flat-rate appeal. If you run a busy retail or hospitality venue with serious POS integration needs and higher volumes, Tyro's specialist focus and volume-aware pricing may suit. If you want everything under one established institution and have the turnover to negotiate, a major bank's EFTPOS offering can bundle banking with payments. Square remains a capable choice; these simply lean toward different priorities.

The independent option

MerchantRates is independent and not affiliated with Square, Tyro, Zeller or any bank. Rather than pushing one provider, we help you compare fee models side by side so the trade-offs between flat-rate simplicity, interchange-style pricing and negotiated bank plans are easy to see. Because the most cost-effective option depends on your average transaction size, monthly volume and card mix, we focus on how each model behaves for your numbers. Use our comparisons to build a shortlist, then confirm current rates and terms with each provider before deciding.

All pricing and feature information on this page is general and indicative only, and is correct to the best of our knowledge at the time of writing. MerchantRates is independent and not affiliated with Square, Tyro, Zeller or any bank or provider mentioned. We do not guarantee any savings; the most suitable option depends on your individual circumstances. Always confirm current rates, fees and terms directly with each provider before making a decision.
Common questions
Square Alternatives, answered
Why would I switch away from Square?
Many businesses are happy with Square, but its flat-rate pricing can become costly as card volume grows. You might also want deeper point-of-sale integrations, local EFTPOS hardware, or a bundled business account. Exploring alternatives helps you check whether another fee model would suit your trading pattern better.
Is Tyro or Zeller cheaper than Square?
It depends entirely on your transaction size, monthly volume and card mix, so there is no universal answer. Zeller uses a flat-rate model broadly similar to Square, while Tyro leans toward volume-aware or negotiated pricing. Compare the models against your actual figures and confirm current rates with each provider directly.
Do I need to switch banks to change my EFTPOS provider?
Not necessarily. Independent providers like Tyro and Zeller can work alongside your existing bank account, with settlement into the account you nominate. Major bank EFTPOS offerings, by contrast, are usually bundled with that bank's business banking. Check each provider's settlement and account requirements before deciding.
Can I negotiate merchant fees in Australia?
Often, yes, particularly if you have meaningful card turnover. Major banks and some providers may offer negotiated or interchange-style rates for higher-volume businesses, while flat-rate providers tend to publish fixed pricing. It is worth asking each provider what they can offer based on your volume before committing.
Does MerchantRates recommend one provider?
No. MerchantRates is independent and not affiliated with any provider. We compare fee models and features so you can see the trade-offs clearly, but the right choice depends on your business. We encourage you to use our comparisons as a starting point and verify current pricing and terms directly with each provider.
Related reading
Square vs Tyro →Best merchant providers in Australia →How to prepare for 2026 →Savings calculator →All comparisons →

Ready to pay less?

Get a free, independent comparison across 20+ Australian payment providers. No obligation — and if we can't beat your rate, we'll pay you $100.

Get my free rate comparison